Restaurant Reviews

a traditional family Italian restaurant for all seasons Review by Sue Giustino Elegantly perched atop one of the highest points in Montauk overlooking Fort Pond …more

Dining at South Edison is always a treat – from start to finish, flavors abound. I first met South Edison’s talented Owner/Executive Chef, Frank Fuschetto, …more

Located in the Westlake Marina at 352 Westlake Drive, the Fish House is as Montauk as it gets. Restaurateurs James and Laura Lyons along with …more

by Sue Giustino Located across from the northwestern edge of Fort Pond on Second House Rd., the Grill at Ruschmeyers opened in May under new …more

by Sue Giustino Montauk offers a variety of dining experiences, from casual seafood shacks to upscale restaurants, many with outdoor seating and/or waterfront views. With such …more

by Evelyn J. Mocbeichel While there are so many things to do when visiting Montauk, one of the best is probably dining out with good …more

A review by Sue Giustino  –  Photos by Lorraine Salvato At the end of the North Fork- a bit past Greenport and just before the …more

by Sue Giustino Celebrating a special birthday, we were thrilled to have a delicious meal at the all-new Ocean Club. The elegant woodwork in the …more

by Sue Giustino Living in Montauk affords its residents and visitors an array of intriguing choices for dining. One of the tried-and-true favorites which has …more

by Debra Rose The Ultimate Dinner Party Going strong since 2005, ‘The Shack,’ ‘The Gig,’ or ‘668’ as it is affectionally called, has a knack …more

‘Elevated All Day Delights’ by Sue Giustino Long time Montauk establishment, the Bird on the Roof has been impressing visitors and locals since the early …more

by Sue Giustino Located along the old highway in a lovely white house with a quaint wraparound porch and spectacular view of the ocean, the …more

by Sue Giustino a conveniently located eatery specializing in Asian Dishes and Sushi In March of ’23 Johnny Lin and his partner Fan found the …more

by Sue Giustino Local Captain Kyle Harrison has partnered up with Aiden Stenson bringing a fresh new vibe to Montauk Harbor.  Along with Local Chef, …more

by Sue Giustino Located in the heart of Montauk, Muse @ The End has become a venue for fine dining, music, and happy hour specials. …more

Respect the Ocean. Harvest the Bounty. Feed the People by Sue Giustino Since 2006, Inlet Seafood Restaurant has been owned and operated by 6 longtime friends …more

by Sue Giustino A long history of fine Italian dining continues with the establishment of Monte’s at the Manor. The Manor itself is special – …more

by Sue Giustino For many years, Jun (Johnny) Lin has been working at many of Montauk’s Sushi kitchens. In the spring of2020, realizing Montauk’s growing need …more

by Sue Giustino 10 years ago, James and Laura Lyons began their Westlake Fish House endeavor here in Montauk – and today they have one …more

by Sue Giustino Since they opened in 2010, Navy Beach has been the one restaurant in Montauk where you can dine with your feet in …more

by Sue Giustino A bit of Scandinavia right here in Montauk. Charolette and Zach, of the Hideaway have incorporated the western coast cuisine of Sweeden …more

By Sue Giustinio – Photos by Lorraine Salvato For many, many years Bird on the Roof was one of Montauk’s most well-known and popular breakfast …more

by Sue Giustino Montauk is home to some of the best local fish anywhere, caught right off our shores. You can find many restaurants and …more

by Sue Giustino Each season Montauk experiences changes; venues change names, chefs, and menus.  The Montauk Yacht Club has done all three. Although the venue …more

by Sue Giustino As winter nears the end, the Montauk restaurants that took a hiatus for the colder months are once again opening their doors …more

by Debbie Tuma If you’re looking for a casual, fun restaurant and bar with a nice atmosphere and water views, Sammy’s is the place for …more

by Sue Giustino Beautiful décor, a welcoming spacious bar with bartenders mixing up creative tasty cocktails, reliable delicious menu, an overall sophisticated ambiance… this is …more

by Sue Giustino If you’ve been in town, heading down South Euclid Avenue, you may have seen the renovations happening on the patio and in …more

…Respect the Ocean. Harvest the Bounty. Feed the People. by Sue Giustino The Inlet Seafood Restaurant at the end of East Lake Dr. has been …more

by Sue Giustino Located in the heart of Montauk since 2018, MTK Lobster House is owned and operated by the Flores family. In July of …more

by Sue Giustino In his fourth season as owner/Chef, Frank Fuschetto continues to wow diners with his impressive menu. Since his transition from Head Chef, …more

Welcome Back Amy! by Sue Giustino After a one-year hiatus, Amy and her crew are back and ready for a great season. There’s been a …more

Seaside Fare with a Mediterranean Flair by Sue Giustino Head Chef George Nikolopoulos has eloquently created a menu with a nod to his Greek heritage. …more

by Sue Giustino ‘casual dockside mexican food by a few Montauk amigos’ After years of enjoying The Hideaway– tucked away at Cove Marina, previous owners …more

by Sue Giustino Rested and ready for the 2022 season, Chef Larry Wallace and his staff at the Inlet Seafood Restaurant are off to a …more

by Sue Giustino Sel Rrose Montauk and Chef Hewitt continue to offer menus highlighting local fish and produce of each season. As autumn unfolds, so …more

Just steps off the beach in town, this lovely gathering place has brought a new feel to the Montauk beach scene. Casual, friendly, and delicious, …more

by Sue Giustino Lynn’s Hula Hut creation is a long way from where it began. This adventure started with a mobile Tiki-bar that Lynn created …more

by Sue Giustino Sandbar Montauk is Located at Royal Atlantic Hotel – offering a newly renovated Oceanfront Tiki Bar & Restaurant. On the beach in …more

by Sue Giustino As always, this family friendly waterfront gem is a great place for afternoon or evening drinks and dining; offering in and outdoor …more

by Sue Giustino Many people have been to The Point Bar and Grill on Main Street in the heart of Montauk.   The pub/sports bar attraction …more

by Sue Giustino UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT! The Montauk Manor is happy to announce that their restaurant is under new management- the new HILLTOP MANOR RESTAURANT …more

by Sue Giustino After a brief hiatus from in-house dining, Shagwongs is open for business and prepped with a new Chef and menu for your …more