Ditch Plains 4 Bedroom Moments From Beach

Wax up your surfboard and come see 31 Otis Road. Located moments from famous Ditch Plains Beach, this home offers a well-situated Montauk opportunity with strong rental appeal and a true connection to the local community surf vibe. This 1,540-square-foot home features 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a spacious deck. A fully cleared backyard and outdoor shower add to the easy summer living. Set in one of Montauk’s most sought-after areas, the property offers convenient access to the beach and to the lifestyle that draws buyers to the East End. A compelling option for those seeking a Montauk home with rental potential and proximity to one of the area’s best-known surf and beach destinations.

Contact: Liz Lycke
Phone: 631-960-8801
Price: $2,825,000
Web ID# 934903

Buildable Lot 2 Blocks To The Atlantic Ocean

Prime buildable lot in Montauk’s coveted Hither Hills community, just two blocks from the ocean. This rare offering is 100% clearable with no wetland issues, providing a clean slate for your custom Hamptons beach house. Enjoy deeded Hither Hills beach rights, including key access to all Hither Hills Association oceanfront parking lots, making beach days simple and convenient. The property’s proximity to Montauk’s renowned beaches, surf, restaurants, and village amenities offers an ideal blend of privacy and accessibility. Create a coastal retreat or year-round residence in one of Montauk’s most desirable neighborhoods, with strong long-term value and excellent investment potential.

Contact: Peter Moore Sr.
Phone: 516-313-0685
Price: $1,650,000
Web ID# 934160

Three Quarter Acre Buildable Lot in Montauk

Three Quarter Acre Buildable Lot in Montauk – Prime buildable three-quarter-acre lot in Montauk, ideally situated up a private road directly across from the renowned Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course. This rare land opportunity offers a peaceful setting with a sense of privacy while keeping you close to everything that makes Montauk so desirable. Centrally located between Montauk Village, the ocean beaches, the harbor and dock area, marinas, and popular local restaurants, this property is an excellent site for a future custom home or investment property. The location provides convenient access to golf, boating, fishing, dining, and shopping, as well as Montauk’s world-famous coastline and outdoor recreation. With its generous size and sought-after position near Montauk Downs, this parcel presents a compelling opportunity for buyers looking to build in one of the Hamptons’ most iconic seaside communities. Buyers should perform their own due diligence regarding permits, zoning, and building potential.

Contact: Peter Moore Sr.
Phone: 516- 313-0685
Price: $775,000
Web ID# 933280

CONVENIENT TO ALL IN MONTAUK WITH SECOND FLOOR LAKE VIEWS

CONVENIENT TO ALL IN MONTAUK WITH SECOND FLOOR LAKE VIEWS – Minutes from the ocean, golf course, harbor, and town, this well-located coastal home offers convenience, privacy, and low-maintenance living. Set on just under an acre, the property enjoys tranquil lake views from the second floor and a virtually maintenance-free exterior, ideal for a lock-and-leave lifestyle or year-round residence. The home features 4 bedrooms and 3.5 baths, providing flexible space for everyday living, guests, or a dedicated home office. A sun-filled eat-in kitchen anchors the main level, offering an inviting spot for casual dining and daily meal prep, while the separate dining room accommodates more formal entertaining. The living room is highlighted by a cozy fireplace and a wet bar, creating a comfortable setting for relaxing or hosting gatherings. A large two-car garage supplies ample storage and parking, adding to the home’s practicality. There is also a conveniently located outdoor shower for those days when you get home from a long beach day. With its close proximity to the shoreline, golf course, harbor area, and town center, this property is well suited as a primary home, vacation retreat, or investment property in a desirable coastal community. Scenic lake views, easy-care exterior features, and a convenient location combine to make this a compelling opportunity for buyers seeking coastal real estate with strong lifestyle appeal.

Contact: Helen Stubbman
Phone: 631-375-3778
Price: $2,500,000
Web ID# 932885

58 Startop Drive With Forever View Over Lake Montauk and Beyond

58 Startop Drive With Forever View Over Lake Montauk and Beyond – Perched on a 1.3-acre hilltop adjoining a 2-acre Peconic Land Trust preserve, this shingled Montauk carriage-style home offers sweeping lake, ocean, harbor, and sunset views in a private resort-like setting. Designed for seamless indoor-outdoor living, the residence centers around a heated 20 x 40 lakeview gunite pool, stone-covered porches, and broad, manicured lawns. A dramatic two-story living room with a beach stone fireplace anchors the main level, flooded with natural light and flowing into a formal dining area and a gourmet kitchen with a breakfast nook. The first-floor primary suite features his-and-hers closets, a spacious bath, and direct access to the pool terrace, creating a true retreat. A separate main-level guest wing, with its own entrance and direct access to the pool and lawn, offers excellent privacy for visitors or extended stays. Upstairs, a junior suite includes a waterview sitting room, private deck, and bath. Two additional guest bedrooms, a full bath, and a media/study room complete the second floor, providing flexible space for work or relaxation. Carlyle Pine flooring throughout enhances the home’s refined yet relaxed coastal character. The fully finished lower level, with 10-foot ceilings, expands the living space significantly and includes a wet bar, theater, bedroom, office, gym, and 1.5 baths, ideal for entertaining, fitness, and remote work. A two-car garage and mature landscaping round out this thoughtfully planned property. Combining elevated views, substantial acreage, and a versatile floor plan, this Montauk estate delivers a rare blend of luxury, comfort, and privacy in a highly desirable East End location.

Contact: Peter Moore Sr.
Phone: 516- 313-0685
Price: $8,450,000
Web ID# 929308

Oceanfront Condo in Montauk

Oceanfront Condo in Montauk – Discover the ultimate oceanfront lifestyle at Montauk Shores Condominium in Ditch Plains, where breathtaking views and coastal living converge. This exceptional property offers unparalleled proximity to the ocean, making it a paradise for surf enthusiasts and fishing aficionados alike. Imagine waking up to the soothing sound of waves and enjoying panoramic ocean views through your expansive front window. Montauk Shores is more than just a home; it’s a vibrant community offering a wealth of amenities designed to enhance your living experience. Dive into relaxation with a heated swimming pool or gather with friends and neighbors at the community clubhouse, a hub for social events and private gatherings. The on-site management and full-time maintenance staff ensure a seamless living experience, while the gated entrance and security provide peace of mind. Families will appreciate the children’s playground, and everyone can enjoy the organized community events that foster a sense of belonging. Whether you’re seeking a serene retreat or an active lifestyle, Montauk Shores Condominium delivers. Experience the perfect blend of natural beauty and modern convenience in this sought-after location. Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of oceanfront paradise. Contact: Helen Stubbman. Phone: . Price:

Contact: Helen Stubbman
Phone: 631-375-3778
Price: $2,890,000
Web ID# 926932

Coastal living in Ditch Plains

Coastal living in Ditch Plains – This is a great opportunity to own in the famous Montauk Shores Condominiums that sits on the Atlantic Ocean in Ditch plains. Easy and tranquil year-round or summer living awaits you in this 2 bedroom 1 bath standalone well maintained beach condo. The surf breaks are at your disposal up and down ditch plains beach and direct access to a lifeguarded area is only a stone’s throw away. Hear the waves crash from your deck or watch the whales and dolphins play from one of three common decks on the dunes. The community features two heated pools, clubhouse and a community gardens. One of the common comments from owners and tenants are, “this is a magical place that is hard to leave.”. There is a low HOA’s of $150 per year and has had strong rental income. Call for a private showing.

Contact: Betsy Cronley
Phone: 516-220-7901
Price: $995,000
Web ID# 894498

MONTAUK OCEANFRONT ACRE WITH PLANS AND PERMITS

MONTAUK OCEANFRONT ACRE WITH PLANS AND PERMITS – Survey attached is a TO BE BUILT Survey. 42 Surfside Avenue presents a rare opportunity to own an acre of true oceanfront in Montauk’s highly sought-after Surfside area. This exceptional parcel combines a premier beachfront setting with the convenience of being close to Montauk’s shops, dining, and transportation, making it one of the most desirable locations on the East End. The property is being offered with finished architectural plans and permits already in place, streamlining the process for a future owner to create a custom oceanfront residence. Building Permit in place is for 5 bedrooms and 3300 sq ft main structure, 585 sq ft attached garage, 420 sq ft gunite pool, and 197 sq ft pool house. With direct frontage on one of Montauk’s most captivating stretches of beach, the site offers sweeping Atlantic Ocean views, soothing surf sounds, and an expansive sandy shoreline just beyond your doorstep. Surfside is favored for its blend of privacy and accessibility, and 42 Surfside Avenue captures that balance perfectly. The lot provides ample space for a thoughtfully designed home, outdoor living areas, with a pool and pool house. The existing plans and permits add significant value, saving time and effort in navigating the building process. This is a rare chance to secure an oceanfront property in a prime Montauk location, with much of the groundwork already completed. Experience coastal living at its finest in a serene, dramatic ocean setting, and create a legacy beach home on one of Montauk’s most remarkable shorefronts.

 

Contact: Helen Stubbman
Phone: 631-375-3778
Price: $15,000,000
Web ID# 4407

Coastal Sanctuary: 1.5 Blocks from the Ocean

Experience the Montauk lifestyle in this charming 3-bedroom home, perfectly situated less than 1,000 feet from the Atlantic Ocean with private beach rights. This residence has partial ocean views and offers a nice blend of Zen tranquility and beachy vibes. The elevated living area, designed by a family member, offers comfort and natural lighting for a cozy gathering alongside the wood burning stove. The Kitchen features a cathedral wood paneled ceiling adding warmth to this open layout with an expansive island and dining space creating the perfect entertaining place to gather with family and friends. Just through wood framed sliding doors you will find a beautiful specimen tree and gardens with decking ideal for alfresco dining. Down the hallway, you will find the primary bedroom featuring an en-suite bathroom with a soaker tub and glass door sliders that lead to a private deck. Two additional guest rooms provide plenty of space for family and visitors. This Hither hills property has a proven record of strong rental income because of its charm and its proximity to the beautiful Hither Hills ocean beaches. Call for an appointment to see and own this Gem by the sea.

Contact: Betsy Cronley & Jeanne Corin
Phone: 516-220-7901 | 516-353-0533
Price: $2,250,000
Web ID# 932224

Classic Elegance in the Heart of Montauk

Welcome to 8 South Ferncroft Place, a distinguished residence nestled in the serene and sought-after locale of Montauk, NY. This exceptional property offers an unparalleled blend of classic design and modern convenience, perfectly situated to capture beautiful lake views. A stone’s throw from Ditch Plains beach and Montauk’s harbor and Montauk Yacht Club. Spanning an impressive 4,300 square feet, this home features five bedrooms and six well-appointed bathrooms, providing ample space for both relaxation and entertainment. The property is designed with an emphasis on indoor-outdoor living, featuring a large upstairs deck and a downstairs covered patio, ideal for enjoying the tranquil surroundings. The heart of the home is the gourmet kitchen, showcasing custom mahogany cabinets and elegant granite countertops. This space is complemented by state-of-the-art appliances and an expansive island for prepping and casual dining. A multi-room sound system ensures a seamless experience for hosting gatherings or enjoying quiet evenings at with friends. This home has a finished basement, perfect additional space for those unexpected weekend guests, as well as separate space for storage. For those who appreciate convenience and luxury, the property is equipped with an elevator, a whole house generator, a FlowLogic Water Monitor System and an 8-zone heating/cooling system. The two fireplaces add warmth and ambiance, while the heated two-car garage provides comfort and ease during the colder months. The exterior of the home is equally impressive, with a park-like setting that offers room for a pool, should you desire. An irrigation system ensures the lush landscaping remains vibrant throughout the seasons. This property is not only a home but a retreat, offering privacy and tranquility in one of Montauk’s most desirable areas. This residence is an exceptional opportunity for those seeking a sophisticated lifestyle in a prime location. With its blend of classic elegance and modern amenities, 8 South Ferncroft Place is a testament to fine living. Schedule a viewing today to experience the unique charm and unparalleled quality of this Montauk gem.

Contact: Gabrielle J. Portella
Phone: 917-327-7205
Price: $5,500,000
Web ID# 924820

West Facing Vacant Lot with Sunsets and Fort Pond Bay Views

Positioned in one of Montauk’s most sought-after locations, this elevated 1.3± acre corner lot offers sweeping, unobstructed water views over Fort Pond Bay and out toward Gardiner’s Island. Surrounded by multimillion-dollar homes and directly across from protected land, the property provides a rare opportunity to create a substantial new construction residence with pool, subject to permits and approvals. The site’s natural elevation maximizes dramatic sunsets and panoramic bay vistas, while this placement enhances privacy and design flexibility. Nearby paths lead to bay beach access, and the property is conveniently located a short distance from Montauk’s ocean beaches, town amenities, and harbor area, offering easy access to dining, shopping, boating, and transportation. With its combination of premier water views, privacy, and proximity to Montauk’s key destinations, this parcel is an exceptional canvas for a custom home in a highly desirable coastal setting.

Contact: Helen Stubbman
Phone: 631-375-3778
Price: $3,200,000
Web ID# 931038

Montauk Hillside Retreat with Pool and Possibilities

Elegantly renovated and set on a lush 0.71-acre hillside parcel bordering preserved land, this three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath residence offers privacy, scale, and a strong connection to its natural surroundings, with the possibility for a pool house. Tucked away on a cul-de-sac with no through traffic, the property offers a sense of quiet and seclusion. The main level unfolds from a central entry into two distinct, light-filled living areas, with a beautifully designed kitchen opening to the dining area and living area, and a separate living/media room-featuring an oversized projection wall set above a wood-burning fireplace-providing a more private retreat. An oversized deck spans the full width of the home with access from either side, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor flow for dining and lounging. Set into the hillside, the pool and hot tub occupy a lower level, maintaining both separation and visual connection, with an outdoor shower completing the setting. The upper level features an en-suite primary bedroom, along with two additional guest rooms and a full hall bath, while the lower level offers additional space with a range of possibilities, all within close proximity to Montauk’s beaches, dining, and village amenities.

Contact: Maria Usher
Phone: 516-521-1167
Price: $3,200,000
Web ID# 930506

Buildable Half Acre Lot One Tenth Mile to Napeague Bay

Presenting an exceptional opportunity to build your dream home at 78 Bay View Avenue, Amagansett, NY. This flat, buildable lot measures 90′ x 240′ and is ideally situated just one-tenth of a mile from the pristine sandy beaches of Napeague Bay. The property offers ample space to construct a 3,000 sq. ft. home, along with a pool and pool house, all without the need for a Natural Resource Special Permit. The location provides stunning natural beauty, with picturesque sunsets over Napeague Bay and serene sunrises over an 11-acre preserve that borders the property to the east. This unique setting ensures both privacy and a connection to the surrounding landscape. This prime piece of real estate in Amagansett is perfect for those looking to create a custom residence in a sought-after area known for its natural charm and coastal lifestyle. Don’t miss this rare chance to secure a lot in such a desirable location.

Contact: Peter Moore Sr.
Phone: 516- 313-0685
Price: $1,250,000
Web ID# 919755

Prime Mixed-Use Commercial/Residential Opportunity in Montauk

An exceptional opportunity to own a versatile mixed-use property in the heart of Montauk, just 200 steps from the ocean with breathtaking sunrise and sunset views. Situated on 0.19 acres, this 2,723 SF, two-story building offers the rare combination of commercial potential and modern residential living – ideal for investors, entrepreneurs, or end-users seeking both lifestyle and income in one of the East End’s most coveted locations. Originally built in 1963, the property underwent a comprehensive renovation in 2023, blending updated finishes with solid construction. A newly constructed apartment, completed in 2024, adds significant value and flexibility – perfect for owner occupancy, staff housing, or strong rental income potential. The property features three full baths and thoughtfully designed space across two levels, allowing for a variety of commercial uses while maintaining comfortable, contemporary residential accommodations. With the Atlantic Ocean just steps away and Montauk’s vibrant shops, restaurants, and beaches nearby, this property offers the ultimate live/work coastal experience. Opportunities that combine location, flexibility, recent renovations, and ocean proximity are increasingly rare. Whether you envision retail, office, gallery, hospitality, or a dynamic live/work concept, this property delivers exceptional potential in one of Montauk’s most sought-after settings.

 

Contact: Sam Crumm
Phone: 914-844-1429
Price: $4,195,000
Web ID# 928846

Cozy Co-op By the Sea  

Discover coastal living at its finest with this wonderful year-round co-op, perfectly situated just steps from the Atlantic Ocean and Hither Hills beaches. Enjoy beautiful ocean views from your large covered deck, with private access and overlooking a serene rolling lawn. The thoughtfully renovated open kitchen and living area, complete with a cozy fireplace, creates an inviting atmosphere for relaxation and entertaining. With the beach less than 400 feet away, this property offers unparalleled convenience for beach lovers. Additional amenities include on-site laundry, basement storage, designated parking, basic cable and a dedicated year-round property manager. Embrace the opportunity for convenient and luxurious living near both the beach and town in this exceptional co-op.

Contact: Gabrielle J. Portella
Phone: 917-327-7205
Price: $650,000
Web ID# 927161

Pristine Lake Montauk Waterfront Land

Pristine Lake Montauk Waterfront Land: Located on a beautiful stretch of Lake Montauk where the views are wide and the beach is sandy, 329 East Lake Drive sets the bar for buildable lakefront land. The 0.87-acre upland portion of the property spans over 260 feet from the road, where elevation is highest, down to the water where 135 feet of shoreline forms a rare private sandy beach. The southwest-facing building envelope is well positioned to enjoy daily sunsets and summer breezes off the lake. It allows for the construction of a nearly 4,000 square-foot house plus an additional lower level, garage, pool and accessory structure – all with the potential for ground-level water views. Whether you’re mooring a boat on your own acre of lake bottom, launching a kayak or paddleboard from your private shoreline, 329 East Lake Drive offers the full experience of waterfront living in one of Montauk’s most picturesque settings. The property is three minutes to Gin Beach, six minutes to the ocean and 100 feet from more than 860 contiguous acres of preserved County land containing Big Reed Pond and miles of trails and protected coastline.

Contact: Peter Moore Jr.
Phone: 631-807-4635
Price: $3,995,000
Web ID# 924715

Fabulous New Modern Ditch Plains 4 Bedroom Home with Pool

Fabulous New Modern Ditch Plains 4 Bedroom Home with Pool –

Discover your new home in Ditch Plains, just four blocks from the renowned surf breaks. This newly constructed traditional residence spans over 2,200 square feet and features 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and a host of modern amenities. Upon entering, the first level welcomes you with three guest bedrooms, including one ensuite, two full bathrooms, a laundry room, and access to both the basement and backyard. Ascend to the second story to find a luxurious primary suite complete with a walk-in closet, double sink vanity, large shower, sauna, and a soaking tub within a stylish wet room. The main living area on the second floor offers an open kitchen, a great room with an attractive fireplace setting the ambiance for the large open living area, a half bath, and a pantry. Step out onto the wrap-around hardwood deck to enjoy views of the brand-new in-ground swimming pool and from this second story deck, you can access the roof deck with 360-degree views, including some ocean views. The full-height, walk-out basement provides ample opportunity for future expansion and additional entertainment space. Buyers have the unique opportunity to select some finishing options, making this home truly their own. Be the first to own this exceptional new construction in Ditch Plains. Keep in mind if you move forward and finish the lower level you are almost at 3000 sq ft and with the new town codes you would not be able to replicate this size home on this size parcel.

 

Contact: Helen Stubbmann & Jared Godsell
Phone: 631-375-3778 | 516-314-4847
Price: $3,750,000
Web ID# 889339